Glyphosate 95% TC vs IPA Salt 41% SL: Normalize First

A chemical drum standing on an industrial platform scale with a clear sight gauge tube beside it, showing one container measured two ways
A 95% TC quote measures acid by mass; a 41% SL measures IPA salt by volume. Normalize both, check two impurity denominators, and write the RFQ that way.
On this page

Glyphosate 95% TC versus glyphosate IPA salt 41% SL is not a comparison between two strengths. It is a comparison between two measurement bases: acid mass in a solid, salt mass in a liquid. Read them as though they shared one scale, and the cheaper quotation is often the costlier product.

1. Five numbers for one glyphosate product

Start with a document nobody argues with. GLYPEX 4, EPA Reg. No. 93033-3, is an approved label for a glyphosate isopropylamine salt formulation. On one page it prints three different numbers for what is, inside the drum, one material:

     · 41.0% by weight

     · Contains 480 grams per liter … in the form of its isopropylamine salt

     · Equivalent to 356 grams per liter … of the acid

Three statements, three different quantities, none of them wrong. Add the figure a technical-material specification uses, and the bare 41% a quotation usually carries, and five numbers are in play for one product:

The same active ingredient, counted five ways. Only one column is comparable without arithmetic.
What the document saysWhat the number countsBasis
41.0% by weight (label)isopropylamine saltmass fraction, salt
480 g/L (label)isopropylamine saltmass per volume, salt
356 g/L acid equivalent (label)glyphosate acidmass per volume, acid
950 g/kg minimum (FAO 284/TC)glyphosate acidmass fraction, acid
41% SL (quotation)isopropylamine salt, usuallymass fraction, salt, per the seller’s declaration
The last row is not a fifth quantity. It is the same 41% as it arrives on a quotation, with no basis attached — which is the problem the rest of this article works on.

One figure is stated in acid, the other in salt. Putting 95% and 41% on the same line means converting one of them, and that conversion is the whole of the comparison.

The salt-to-acid coefficient is 0.741 — the molecular weight of the acid divided by the molecular weight of its isopropylamine salt. You can check that figure without leaving this page: on the GLYPEX 4 label, 356 ÷ 480 gives 0.7417 — the same coefficient, sitting a little high because both label figures are rounded to three digits. Applied to it, 41.0% by weight of salt is 30.4% by weight of acid, or 304 g/kg; the same coefficient turns 480 g/L of salt into 356 g/L of acid, the figure the label already states.

The method is not re-derived here: the 2,4-D acid-equivalent arithmetic covers it once, properly. What matters in this comparison is narrower. When a supplier writes 95% on one line and 41% on another, the two percentages sit on opposite sides of that coefficient.

2. What 95% TC counts, and what 41% SL counts

95% TC is quoted as a mass fraction of acid: not less than 950 g/kg. There is nothing volumetric about it. A kilogram of Glyphosate 95% TC holds 950 g of glyphosate acid whatever the ambient temperature of the warehouse it is sitting in.

41% SL is a different kind of quantity. The 41 is a glyphosate IPA salt percentage by weight, but the product moves by volume: liters, drums, IBCs. FAO 284/SL defines the volumetric declaration at 20 ± 2 °C. Two bases in one product — a mass percentage in the name, a volume quantity in the transaction. Glyphosate Isopropylamine Salt 41% SL carries both, and most data sheets print whichever one suits the seller.

FAO has already settled which one governs. Note 2 of the SL specification deals with the buyer who asks for both g/kg and g/L, and states that in case of dispute, the analytical results shall be calculated as g/kg. That single sentence is the hierarchy. Mass is the referee. Volume is a delivery habit.

Volume expands with temperature; mass does not. A drum sealed at one temperature and sampled at another returns two different g/L figures for one material, and the same g/kg figure both times.

A buyer negotiating per liter, per drum or per IBC is buying mass and signing volume. That convention works, right up to one moment: when the figure on that page is compared against a TC quotation that was never volumetric. You cannot subtract a mass fraction from a volume concentration, and you cannot put a landed cost per liter next to one per kilogram without a density in between.

A chemical drum standing on an industrial platform scale with a clear sight gauge tube beside it, showing one container measured two ways

3. The shape of a tolerance, not its size

TC has a floor, not a band. FAO 284/TC declares acid content as not less than 950 g/kg, and the requirement is that the measured value shall not be lower than the declared minimum. One edge. A TC supplier is exposed to being short; there is no upper limit to breach.

SL is banded. FAO 284/SL sets tolerance by declared content:

Tolerance by declared acid content. A standard 41% SL sits in the middle tier.
Declared content (g/kg or g/L)Permitted tolerance
up to 25± 15% of the declared content
25 to 100± 10%
100 to 250± 6%
250 to 500± 5%
above 500± 25 g/kg or g/L
Tolerances as printed in FAO Specification 284/SL (February 2016). Each tier includes its upper limit.

A 41% SL declaring 304 g/kg of acid, or 480 g/L of salt, lands in the 250 to 500 band and takes the ± 5%. Two edges. The supplier can fail short and can fail long.

A floor and a band are different risk objects, and that asymmetry is what the buyer has to price. Ask a TC supplier what happens above 950 g/kg and the honest answer is that nobody has a claim. Ask an SL supplier what happens at the top of the band and you learn whether they control a process or only a certificate.

The conversation usually goes wrong because both sides start at the number and never describe the shape. Reading a COA line by line is where the shape question belongs, because a COA is the only document that prints the measured value next to the declared one.

4. Two impurity limits, two denominators

Two rows in the specification below do not share a denominator, and reading a spec table row by row is how you see it.

FAO 284/SL, February 2016, lists two relevant impurities with numeric limits, and the two limits are measured against different things:

The two relevant impurity limits in FAO 284/SL, and what each one is measured against.
ImpurityLimitDenominator
Formaldehydemax 1.3 g/kgper kg of glyphosate acid
N-Nitrosoglyphosate (NNG)max 1 mg/kgabsolute, per kg of material
Both limits are printed on the same page of the specification and look interchangeable on a certificate. They are not.

The FAO evaluation text is explicit on both. For formaldehyde, the limit was set to 1.3 g/kg on a glyphosate acid basis. For NNG, in this exceptional case, not related to the content of glyphosate acid.

One limit scales with how much acid the material carries. The other does not.

Put a TC COA and an SL COA side by side and you get the misreading you would expect. A 950 g/kg acid solid carries about 3.1 times the acid per kilogram of material that a 304 g/kg liquid does. If both sit at the same fraction of the formaldehyde limit on an acid basis, the figure on the TC sheet runs about 3.1 times the figure on the SL sheet.

The NNG figures are a different story. Same denominator, same units, directly comparable, no conversion and no assumption. If someone puts two NNG numbers in front of you and asks which material is better controlled, that question has an answer. The formaldehyde question has no answer until you know which basis the laboratory reported on.

One action comes before any judgment about the number: ask for the denominator. Per kilogram of material, or per kilogram of acid. A supplier who cannot say which has handed you a COA that cannot be used for comparison.

5. The step from TC to SL is a capability question

A formulated SL starts as TC, and the step between them is the formulation side of an SL. What it takes: a water source of consistent quality, a base to form the salt, an adjuvant package, and pH control across the batch.

FAO 284/SL Note 5 goes straight at the pH point. The pH of an isopropylamine salt formulation has to be considered. Three species sit in equilibrium: glyphosate acid, the mono-isopropylamine salt and the di-isopropylamine salt. That equilibrium, together with the nature of the adjuvants, determines the crystallization stability of the glyphosate acid. Read that as a description of what the processor actually manages. Not mixing. Holding a three-way equilibrium far enough from the crystallization boundary that the batch passes the checks built to catch it: solution stability through a 45 µm sieve under MT 41.1, and separation after 7 days at 0 ± 2 °C limited to 0.3 ml under MT 39.3.

That reframes the buy decision. A buyer who takes TC instead of SL saves the processing cost and picks up a crystallization exposure. The exposure has a cost of its own: rejected lots, claims, a customer who opens a drum and finds solids at the bottom. Whether it exceeds the processing cost is a calculation only the buyer can run, because it depends on their water, their plant, their container and their customer.

What it should never be is an unexamined assumption that the lower line on the quotation is the cheaper product. The formulation step is not a markup added for convenience. It is work. Decline to pay for it and the work is yours.

6. One number for both: landed cost per kg acid equivalent

Everything above collapses into one figure, and the figure is not a price. It is the landed cost per kilogram of acid equivalent, the only number that puts a 95% TC quotation and a 41% SL quotation in the same units.

The terms:

  • G — goods value of the lot
  • F — freight and insurance to destination
  • P — packaging and container cost
  • M — net mass of the lot in kilograms. For a liquid, net volume in liters times the density in kg/L.
  • a — acid mass fraction as declared
  • L — conversion yield, in kilograms of acid equivalent delivered in salable form per kilogram of acid equivalent purchased
The formula

Landed cost per kg acid equivalent = (G + F + P) ÷ (M × a × L)

For TC, a is the declared minimum, 0.950. For SL, a is the declared salt fraction times 0.741, or the declared acid g/L divided by 1000 times the density in kg/L. For TC bought for resale, L is 1. For TC bought to be formulated, L is your yield, and it is not 1. Put your own number in that slot, not ours, because we do not know your plant.

Two arithmetic checks before you use the formula

Divide declared g/L by declared w/w fraction and you get the density the document implies. On the GLYPEX 4 label, 480 ÷ 0.410 gives 1171 g/L, about 1.17 kg/L. Run that on the sheet in front of you. If a 41% SL document returns 1.02 kg/L, or 1.35 kg/L, one of the two figures is wrong, or the g/L was measured at a temperature nobody recorded. Either way, stop. Every downstream calculation just inherited the error.

The acid line is the second check. 480 g/L of salt times 0.741 gives 356 g/L of acid — the figure the label states, to its own rounding. A sheet where that multiplication does not reproduce the stated acid figure has a transcription fault. A transcription fault in a specification is a fault in the lot.

7. What goes on the RFQ so both suppliers answer the same question

Two quotations are comparable only if the inquiry closed the ambiguities before anyone answered. Six lines do most of that work.

  1. Declared basis. Acid content as g/kg, or as g/L at 20 °C. Write the 20 °C into the inquiry. A g/L figure without a temperature is not a specification.
  2. Tolerance. One-sided floor or two-sided band. If a band, which tier.
  3. Impurity limits and their denominators. Per kg of acid or per kg of material, stated separately for each limit.
  4. Net weight and net volume per pack. Both, on the same line, plus the density used to convert between them.
  5. Container. Type, nominal capacity, and the fill actually used.
  6. Which label items to check. Declared content and its basis, the acid-equivalent statement, the net content, the named salt, and the registration number printed on the pack.

None of the six asks a supplier to disclose anything they would not put in a contract, and all six are things they must know in order to answer at all.

If you would rather not build the comparison yourself, send the six lines to our technical team and we will answer them in the same order.

8. When glyphosate 95% TC wins, when 41% SL wins

Four conditions decide it, and none of them is the quotation.

Formulation capability

With a plant, a water source you trust, and the pH control to hold a salt in solution, TC is your raw material and SL is a product you make. Without those, you are buying a finished product and the processing cost is not optional.

Batch size

Conversion has a minimum run, below which the fixed part of the processing lands on too few tons to pay for itself. A buyer taking two IBCs a season is not in that business.

Packaging and warehousing

TC moves as a dry solid in bags, with the humidity control a powder needs. SL moves as liquid in drums and IBCs, where volume, mass and container weight travel together. Whichever form you can hold without degradation is the one still in specification when it is opened.

Registration dossier match

What is registered is registered as a specific formulation at a specific declared content. A buyer who reformulates changes the declared content, and therefore changes the file. Confirm the current status in the destination country before choosing a form, not after.

The comparison method decides what you bought. Normalize both quotations to acid equivalent before the numbers meet, and a 41% SL that looked more expensive can turn out to be the cheaper acid. Skip the normalization, and the lower figure is a position you have taken on someone else’s process control.

More: more herbicide technical notes.

Next step

Send us your destination and pack size, and we will come back with the basis — declared content and its unit, the tolerance tier, and the acid equivalent per pack — not just the figure. Tell us your destination and pack size.

Sources

The two FAO documents are quoted from the published specification text. Every clause used above was read from the document itself, at the version stated.

FAO — Specifications and Evaluations for Agricultural Pesticides: Glyphosate, FAO Specification 284/TC and 284/SL (February 2016)
Supports: the 950 g/kg minimum and its one-sided requirement, declaration as g/kg or g/L at 20 ± 2 °C, the tiered tolerance table, both impurity limits, the four physical and storage tests under MT 41.1, MT 47.3, MT 39.3 and MT 46.3, Note 2 on calculating as g/kg in a dispute, Note 5 on the isopropylamine equilibrium, and the evaluation text giving the basis of each impurity limit.
FAO — same specification, November 2014 archive (cross-check only, not cited as the current version)
Supports: cross-check only. The figures used above are unchanged between the two editions. Archived material — superseded by the February 2016 edition.
US EPA — GLYPEX 4, EPA Reg. No. 93033-3, approved label amendment, 6 September 2024
Supports: one approved label stating 41.0% by weight, 480 g/L as the isopropylamine salt, and 356 g/L acid equivalent on the same page — which also lets the 0.741 coefficient be checked as 356 ÷ 480. A label describes one product at one date; it is not a specification.
UC Agriculture and Natural Resources — Glyphosate formulations: what’s the difference and what’s the salt?
Supports: label percentages are given by mass while product is traded by volume, and percentages for different salts are not comparable because the molecular weights differ. Archived extension material — revised without notice; confirm the current page before quoting it.
Nothing above is a recommendation to use any product in any particular market. Confirm the version in force for your destination, and the registration that applies to the specific formulation, before a quotation becomes a contract.
Share the Post:

Related Posts

Ready to build your crop protection range?
Tell us the active ingredients, formulations and pack sizes you need. You will normally have a quotation within one business day, including registration documents.